Tickets are not available.

Event Details

True Crime Obsessed with Missing Maura Murray appearing at Underground Arts

Friday, October 1, 2021


  •    Everyone coming to the show must be fully vaccinated. You will need to show proof of your vaccination at the door. If you cannot provide this proof, you will not be allowed into the venue

    •    The first row of seating will be 6 feet from the stage. 

    •    Only drink service will be available inside the theater. Food service will be limited to a separate area outside the theater.  

    •    Masks are required to be worn by everyone at all times. Masks must cover your nose and mouth. You are permitted to lower your mask to take a bite or sip of your food / drink and then must be replaced as you chew and swallow. 

    •    Patrick and Gillian will not be doing any photos or hugs or even handshakes EVEN THOUGH WE REALLY TRULY LOVE YOU.

The disappearance of Maura Murray is one of the most infamous missing persons cases in US history. AND YOU KNOW YOU’RE OBSESSED WITH IT. True Crime Obsessed’s Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle host the unbelievably handsome Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna of the Missing Maura Murray podcast and the beautiful and smart Maggie Freleng of Oxygen’s The Disappearance of Maura Murray for an evening of obsessing over the case. With their signature humor and sass, the TCO team and their guests will talk about new evidence, break down both the Oxygen series AND Lance and Tim’s documentary on the case, and relive the legendary hike to the coordinates. Because Patrick never wants to stop talking about it. Think of it as an obsessive true crime cocktail party – and you’re invited.

Doors for VIP purchasers will open at 6:15pm, and doors for GA purchasers will open at 7:15pm. Please note: timing is subject to change. *

8:00pm Show

True Crime Obsessed is the True Crime / Comedy podcast you need in your life! Each week, hosts Gillian Pensavalle and Patrick Hinds recap true crime documentaries with humor, sass, heart, and just the right amount of snark. In their live show, Gillian and Patrick bring their hilarious take on the absurdities of true crime characters and storylines to the stage, tearing into one of your favorite true crime documentaries using video clips, music, and their signature garbage bell.


In 2017, Patrick and his co-host Gillian Pensavalle launched True Crime Obsessed, a true crime/comedy podcast that recaps true crime documentaries with humor, sass, and a well-timed garbage bell. TCO was an instant hit and quickly became one of the most popular true crime podcasts on the internet. The podcast has recently been featured in the New York Times and Vulture and has sold out live shows in cities across the United States.

Patrick began his podcasting journey in 2013 as the creator, co-producer, and host of the popular Theater People podcast. Theater People was a first of its kind podcast, featuring full-length interviews with Tony winners, Broadway legends, and theater’s brightest stars. Theater People was notably included in NPR’s 2016 hand-picked list of the best podcasts on the internet, was cited by Buzzfeed as one of the 22 best pop-culture podcasts online, and was named an honoree in the category of "Best Podcast" by the 2016 Webby Awards. In 2016, Patrick launched Broadway Backstory, which was nominated for a Webby Award in 2018. He was also tapped by Disney Theatrical Productions to produce and host The Official Disney on Broadway podcast.


With over ten years of experience in the entertainment industry, Gillian is a content creator through and through: she is an actor, voice-over artist, on-camera host, podcaster, editor, writer, SAG signatory producer, and showrunner.

Gillian is the co-creator of True Crime Obsessed, a smash-hit true crime/comedy podcast. Recapping documentaries with their unique blend of humor, heart, and sass, Gillian and her partner Patrick Hinds have garnered over 5000 five-star reviews on Apple Podcasts and are consistently listed in the top 200 of all podcasts. In January 2016, Gillian created The Hamilcast: A Hamilton Podcast, the first Hamilton podcast to hit the airwaves, which she also executive produces and hosts. Many of Hamilton’s creators and stars have appeared on the podcast – including Lin-Manuel Miranda – and it has earned the title of "The Official Hamilton Podcast" among cast members. Together with her husband Michael Paul Smith, Gillian co-created, produced, and starred in The Residuals, a successful comedy series based on the couple's the real-life NYC commercial auditions. As a Senior On-Air Host at Zazoom Media Group, Gillian pitched, wrote, hosted, produced, and edited approximately 2,000 videos for the flagship Buzz60 channel that were distributed to over 12,000 partner sites and garnered tens of millions of views.

Your email has been sent

There was an error sending your message. Please verify the addresses and try again. Note: HTML is not allowed in the subject/message.

Event Location


Underground Arts

1200 Callowhill St., Philadelphia, PA, 19107

Show Map

View 1200 Callowhill St. in a larger map


True Crime Obsessed